MARTIN J DOUGHERTY
  • Home
    • A Quick Guide to MJD
    • Credits Overview
    • Work Availability
  • My Work
    • My Writing Career
    • Mainstream Publishing >
      • Military History Books
      • Fiction
      • Martial Arts & Self-Defence Books >
        • Fight to Win
        • The Self Defence Manual
      • Armed Combat Books
      • Transportation Books
      • Childrens Books
      • Fencing and Martial Arts Books
    • Games Industry >
      • Avenger Enterprises
    • Defence and Security Industry
    • My Television Work
    • Other Work
  • Martial Arts and Fencing
    • My Martial Arts and Fencing Career
    • Fencing >
      • British Federation for Historical Swordplay (BFHS) >
        • BFHS Chief Assessor
        • IL1 Guidance for Candidates
        • IL 2-4 Work in Progresss
      • Smallsword Fencing
      • The Military and Duelling Sabre
      • Olympic, or 'Sport', Fencing
      • Fencing Photos
      • More Fencing Photos
    • MJD Musings >
      • Priority
      • Respect
      • Agendas and Misconceptions
      • Light Sabres, Sabre: Lite....
      • Coach Development in Martial Arts
      • HEMA: Martial Art or Sport?
      • Obstacles to Improvement
      • A Governing Body for HEMA?
      • Scottish HEMA Controversy
      • Grappling: Why Not?
      • Musings on Running a Class
      • Learning to Fence
  • The Society for the Study of Swordsmanship
    • Intoduction to the Class
    • SSS FAQ
    • SSS Equipment and Safety
    • SSS Ranks and Grades
    • SSS Weapons
  • Fiction, Articles and Other Scribblings
    • Short Fiction >
      • Holy Spirits
      • Grand Endeavour
      • Pandora's Box
      • Wheelman
      • Reactivation Clause
      • Although He May Be Poor
      • Into The Hands of God
    • Mancave Playbabes Articles >
      • Fencing Article
      • Edinburgh Article
      • Whisky Article
    • Space Exploration Articles >
      • Reaching Orbit
      • In Orbit
      • Exploration of the Solar System
      • Space Stations
      • Space Stations - White Elephants in the Sky?
  • Avenger Enterprises
    • Starfarers Gazette 0-1
    • Starfarers Gazette 2
    • Starfarers Gazette 3
    • Starfarers Gazette 4
  • My Life and Related Misadventures
    • Perthshire
    • Other Photos
    • Warkworth Castle
    • More Photos
  • Other Stuff
    • Martial Arts & Self-Defence >
      • Combat Ju-Jitsu
      • Self-Defence
      • Nihon Tai-Jitsu
      • Self Defence and the Law
      • The Possibility of Violence
      • Grappling and Groundfighting
      • Anatomy of a Streetfight
    • News, Updates and... Stuff.
    • Conventions, Events and Seminars >
      • Smallsword Symposium
      • Smallsword Symposium 2015
      • SWASH
      • BFHS Spring and Autumn Exchange
    • Northumbria Police: Arrogant, High-Handed and Reckless >
      • Experiences with Northumbria Police
      • Questions But No Answers
      • Concerns About PSD

Trying to Invent HEMA at Warkwarth Castle

Some time ago, when we were young(er) and daft(er), the fencing club received an invitation from a Napoleonic re-enactment group to visit them on one of their displays. They were camping overnight at Warkwarth Castle, doing a 2-day event, and would have the run of the place after the public left.

A couple of my fencers were members of this group, and had been extolling the virtues of the sport to their colleagues. They were keen to try, so we loaded up some extra gear and headed up to the castle. This would be around 1996 or so.

After a brief introduction to safe fencing (which in some cases included a quick conversion from sword drill as taught by the current British Army), we conducted a series of duels against the backdrop of the castle. The following photos were taken inside the castle, which remains rather spectacular as you can see.

What you can't see from the photos is that it was raining heavily. Visibility became poor enough that it was like playing Doom at times; opponents materialising out of the haze in front of you, then fading away again. Very strange. Very wet too. Some of us came close to drowning in our masks…!

It is probably worth pointing out that we were exquisitely careful not to damage the historic ruins of the castle. Indeed, the actual fencing took place away from the ruins. Whether the photos are real or posed recreations of what we got up to outside the castle I'll leave to the reader's imagination.

We fought a series of duels with the three weapons of modern fencing; the foil, the epee and the sabre. Sabre came most naturally to the re-enactors, as might be expected, and we made an interesting discovery - a wet denim shirt makes a nice crunchy sound when struck hard with a sabre blade!

Picture
This is me (in black, of course) vs, err, somebody or other. It might be Chris 'Spanners' or one of his re-enactor buddies.

Picture
Same bout, different angle.

Note the lack of glove, shirtsleeves... yeek!

I would love to claim I'm older and wiser now, but truth be told I'm just older.

However, there were occasional moments of competence. Here my opponent is parrying in the position of Prime as I begin what will become a looping cut to the left side of his head.

Many of our duels were quite long, with brief bursts of activity punctuated by periods of circling and probing for an opening.

Just for reference, that's me in black. There were several guys in grey trousers and white shirts; some could fence and some had been given just 15 minutes' instruction… Sabre vs. sabre was certainly interesting when faced with an opponent who possessed lots of guts and no skill whatsoever!

Aggression was the order of the day, with several of my opponents demonstrating a very British style of swordsmanship; they stormed forward making huge slashes with no regard to their own safety. It was parry or die!
Picture

When there was a clash, things happened pretty fast. Simultaneous attacks were common. Normally one or both of us realised what was happening and skidded to a halt or turned an attack into a hasty parry. And sometimes there was what you might call 'mutual stabbage'.

This is where preparation of attack is useful. A good sharp beat on the opponent's blade as you begin the attack should (*NB: should*) deflect his attack or mess up his defence.

There were few elegant parry-riposte sequences like in the movies. Most of our duels were won by either the first attack or the first parry-riposte (or sometimes, the first awkward-scramble-out-of-the-way-and-desperate-lunge, but it's the principle that counts!). If an initial set-piece attack failed, the usual reaction was horror and frantic backing up to get some distance - close-in stabbing or slashing matches are a bit of a lottery at the best of times.

Picture
Eventually, things got rather silly. Certain less scrupulous members of our company decided that it would be fun to gang up on me. There are few people who would describe being chased across a car park into a 'dry' castle moat in the rain, in near-darkness, by a mob of sword-waving loonies as fun, but I guess I'm one of them.

I won't even try to explain what's going on here…

As an interesting but irrelevant footnote, I ran into a couple of the guys from these photos a while back at an engagement party. Small world…


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
    • A Quick Guide to MJD
    • Credits Overview
    • Work Availability
  • My Work
    • My Writing Career
    • Mainstream Publishing >
      • Military History Books
      • Fiction
      • Martial Arts & Self-Defence Books >
        • Fight to Win
        • The Self Defence Manual
      • Armed Combat Books
      • Transportation Books
      • Childrens Books
      • Fencing and Martial Arts Books
    • Games Industry >
      • Avenger Enterprises
    • Defence and Security Industry
    • My Television Work
    • Other Work
  • Martial Arts and Fencing
    • My Martial Arts and Fencing Career
    • Fencing >
      • British Federation for Historical Swordplay (BFHS) >
        • BFHS Chief Assessor
        • IL1 Guidance for Candidates
        • IL 2-4 Work in Progresss
      • Smallsword Fencing
      • The Military and Duelling Sabre
      • Olympic, or 'Sport', Fencing
      • Fencing Photos
      • More Fencing Photos
    • MJD Musings >
      • Priority
      • Respect
      • Agendas and Misconceptions
      • Light Sabres, Sabre: Lite....
      • Coach Development in Martial Arts
      • HEMA: Martial Art or Sport?
      • Obstacles to Improvement
      • A Governing Body for HEMA?
      • Scottish HEMA Controversy
      • Grappling: Why Not?
      • Musings on Running a Class
      • Learning to Fence
  • The Society for the Study of Swordsmanship
    • Intoduction to the Class
    • SSS FAQ
    • SSS Equipment and Safety
    • SSS Ranks and Grades
    • SSS Weapons
  • Fiction, Articles and Other Scribblings
    • Short Fiction >
      • Holy Spirits
      • Grand Endeavour
      • Pandora's Box
      • Wheelman
      • Reactivation Clause
      • Although He May Be Poor
      • Into The Hands of God
    • Mancave Playbabes Articles >
      • Fencing Article
      • Edinburgh Article
      • Whisky Article
    • Space Exploration Articles >
      • Reaching Orbit
      • In Orbit
      • Exploration of the Solar System
      • Space Stations
      • Space Stations - White Elephants in the Sky?
  • Avenger Enterprises
    • Starfarers Gazette 0-1
    • Starfarers Gazette 2
    • Starfarers Gazette 3
    • Starfarers Gazette 4
  • My Life and Related Misadventures
    • Perthshire
    • Other Photos
    • Warkworth Castle
    • More Photos
  • Other Stuff
    • Martial Arts & Self-Defence >
      • Combat Ju-Jitsu
      • Self-Defence
      • Nihon Tai-Jitsu
      • Self Defence and the Law
      • The Possibility of Violence
      • Grappling and Groundfighting
      • Anatomy of a Streetfight
    • News, Updates and... Stuff.
    • Conventions, Events and Seminars >
      • Smallsword Symposium
      • Smallsword Symposium 2015
      • SWASH
      • BFHS Spring and Autumn Exchange
    • Northumbria Police: Arrogant, High-Handed and Reckless >
      • Experiences with Northumbria Police
      • Questions But No Answers
      • Concerns About PSD